Friday, March 21, 2014

The Truth About Royce Versus Gracie University

The way Royce Gracie has chosen to communicate his opinion to the public is puzzling. Reading the statement by Royce, I found it is very generalized, not well thought out, or articulated well. Royce offers no specifics to support his claims. And he does not offer a published Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Curriculum of his own with a “proper” Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Philosophy to counter what Rener and Ryron have published on Gracie University.  It is sad that he, for whatever reason, decided to make some very alarming claims about the two sons of his brother Rorion (whom allowed Royce to live with him, in his home, after first arriving in America to spread jiu-jitsu to a new place).  It seems Royce just decided to throw his family under the bus without offering any evidence to support his harsh accusations toward them; and without offering a better published curriculum of his own, either in print or online.

We need to ask some questions and Royce needs to answer. Why does Royce claim the curriculum developed by his nephews' is not a true representation of the teaching methods taught to him by his father? Is it because the techniques are incorrectly presented? Is there a valid reason or does Royce simply disapprove of the delivery modality?

Royce asserts the belt grading system does not meet the standards set forth by Grandmaster Helio Gracie. How does he line this statement up with a video of GM Helio approving of the system? This video is published on Gracie University for everyone to view. I have more to mention about belt grading, but will get back to it later.

It seems as though the one thing that triggered this off  for Royce was a statement made by Rener Gracie about “some” students finding the online linear curriculum better than trying to learn from a group class where beginner blue belts are being taught together with purple, brown, and even black belts. Maybe Royce, like many people commenting on the various threads, misunderstood Rener, believing he meant others can’t teach GJJ properly or effectively.  If this is the case, he is wrong. Here is how I know:   After earning a blue belt from a BJJ training center where I live, for personal reasons, I decided to learn from Gracie University.  I have also completed the Instructor Certification Program through the Gracie Academy, as well as trained with Rener, Ryron, and Rorion in person on other occasions. In doing so I have listened to Rener and Ryron speak in great depth about Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Philosophy and Teaching Methodologies.  Specifically, I heard Rener use the same quote (that Royce responded to) comparing online learning to class room learning. However, he elaborated with much greater detail than the short quote found on the twitter account of @realroyce.  Rener explained that students need to be on the mat constantly experimenting with technique, and “learning between the lines”. Rener stated his online instruction and/or classroom instruction could provide 50% of what students need at best. The rest is learned through practice on the mat. He also encouraged rolling with both the gi and no gi, in addition to practicing techniques against striking opponents wearing gloves.

What is more important, and I recall both Rener and Ryron saying this on more than one occasion, is the statements I heard them make about other black belt instructors, especially those from their own family. They asserted that everyone in their extended family understands and knows how to teach Pure Gracie Jiu-Jitsu.

Moving on.

There is a lot of confusion about belt promotions related to Gracie University. First off, everyone reading needs to understand that it is impossible for anyone to be ranked above a “Gracie Combatives” blue belt via video submission through Gracie University. Students test for stripes, but not belts. And this is designed to get them ready for the live, face to face, evaluations for purple, brown, and black belts. To gain a purple, or brown belt, students must be tested by a Designated Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Black Belt. And this happens in person. This does involve all forms of sparring and rolling. To test for black belt, students must be tested by Rener or Ryron themselves. Finally, GU students must train on the mat, preferably a GJJ CTC. Otherwise the progress toward other belts will never happen.  It would be impossible.

Opening a Certified Training Center through the GJJ Academy is a strict process. Those wishing to open a school must first have their rank verified by Rener and Ryron. A level 1 school is the lowest ranking, where students can only be white belts and achieve blue belt under a verified blue belt instructor. Any student at a CTC must have their blue belt test reviewed by a designated Gracie Academy Instructor before the promotion happens--it can happen face to face or video upload. However, blue belt is the only promotion where video evaluation is allowed, the rest are face to face and overseen by black belts. Also, during the first year, new training centers are on  level 1 probation. Instructors must complete many steps for the probation to be lifted or they lose instructor and school status. As instructors advance and prove their worthiness to Rener and Ryron, the certification levels are increased accordingly. Rener and Ryron are active by visiting CTC locations to conduct seminars.  Just like with Gracie University Online, students at level 1, 2, 3, or 4 schools cannot be promoted to purple, or brown belts unless tested by a black belt belt in person. And those students testing for black belt must be tested by Rener or Ryron in person. So video upload is an option at the blue belt level only and is the minimum requirement for all who are testing for blue, whether it is an online student or a CTC student.

Ironically this is information I found on the Royce Gracie website about the way Royce handles affiliate schools. It seems very similar to what Rener and Ryron are doing, except without the video curriculum to help students learn. And maybe without a solid written curriculum, but I can’t speak to this for sure. Once you read what Royce is doing, ask yourselves why he is upset with his nephews for simply adding an extra layer to the delivery process of Gracie Jiu-Jitsu. Maybe his motivation isn’t pure. I don’t know.

 MEMBERSHIP AGREEMENT
ROYCE GRACIE JIU-JITSU NETWORK
MEMBERSHIP AGREEMENT
ROYCE GRACIE JIU-JITSU NETWORK
It is hereby agreed that the person(s) signing this agreement has been selected to be the
representative(s) of the said chapter of the Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™. It is further
agreed that such chapter of the Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ shall abide by the
terms and conditions set forth in this “Membership Agreement for the Royce Gracie Jiu-
Jitsu Network™”.
REQUIREMENTS
Outlined are the basic requirements in order to be eligible and or establish a Royce
Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™
1. Any person(s) establishing the network must be ranked as a Blue Belt and/or
higher in the art of Brazilian/Gracie Jiu-Jitsu®1. Belt ranking must be issued and
or confirmed by Royce Gracie.
2. Any person(s) establishing the chapter must prior to submitting the application
attend and/or part take in a Group/Private Class and or a Seminar with Royce
Gracie, unless such person has already been ranked by Royce Gracie.
3. Any person(s) establishing the chapter must have minimum of 40 (forty) students
ready to join such chapter and/or already training.
4. There must not be an already established chapter of the Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu
Network™ within 50 miles of the applicant’s location.
5. Any person(s) establishing the chapter must host a minimum of 1 (one) Royce
Gracie seminar per calendar year and be willing to host on-site classes with Royce
Gracie and/or another certified instructor a minimum of two times per year.
However, no guarantee is made that Royce Gracie will be present at each location
on a yearly basis.
6. A person(s) establishing the network must conduct a minimum of 2 (two)-class
sessions during a calendar week.
7. A person(s) establishing the network must have adequate facility to conduct such
classes including, but not limited to, a matted area sufficient to hold the current
number of students.
8. Any person(s) establishing the network must have and/or be willing to purchase
adequate liability insurance coverage for the facility, students and any on-site
visitors and/or instructors including but not limited to Royce Gracie. Proof of
such insurance must be submitted with this application.
BELT RANKING
Any person(s) who has attained a rank of a Blue Belt or higher in Brazilian/Gracie
Jiu-Jitsu may apply to become the network representative of the Royce Gracie Jiu-
Jitsu Network™. In the event that such person(s) did not receive his/her ranking from
Royce Gracie, it is required that Royce Gracie confirm such ranking.
If you did not receive your belt from Royce Gracie and wish to become a network
representative of the Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ you must either attend a
Royce Gracie Seminar and/or part take in a Group/Private Class with Royce Gracie,
at which time your belt ranking can be confirmed.
CHAPTER REPRESENTATIVE CLASSIFICATION
The Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ has established a system by which the
network representatives are classified.
Coach
A coach is any Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ representative who has been ranked
and/or confirmed as a Blue Belt by Royce Gracie.
Assistant Instructor
An assistant instructor is any Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ representative who
has been ranked and/or confirmed as a Purple Belt by Royce Gracie. An assistant
instructor must be actively participating in training his network members and has to
exhibit advanced teaching skills under the methods set forth by Royce Gracie.
Instructor
An instructor is any Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ representative who has
completed the instructor-training program and has continuously trained under direct
supervision of Royce Gracie. An instructor must be actively participating in training
his members and has to exhibit advanced teaching skills under the methods set forth
by Royce Gracie
NOTE: Only Royce Gracie and/or a person appointed by Royce Gracie may promote
students. If you do not train with Royce in California you may be promoted at the
Seminars, Network Visits and/or other classes conducted by Royce Gracie.
CLASS INSTRUCTION
Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ representative will conduct a minimum of two
group classes during a calendar week. In addition the chapter representative may
conduct private/semi private classes in the event that the chapter members and/or
other students request such classes. The payment schedule for such group as well as
private and semi-private classes is outlined in the section titled “ Dues & Fees”
Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ chapter representative may also conduct kids
group classes if approved first by Royce Gracie. The minimum age for a child
allowed to participate in such classes is 6 years old and there is to be a maximum of
twelve (12) students per class. A chapter representative must have a consent form
signed by a parent and/or legal guardian of a child prior to beginning any classes.
CLASS FEES & DUES
The Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ has established guidelines for membership
dues as well as training fees that each chapter representative may charge. The
schedule for such fees & dues is based on the classification of the chapter
representative.
CLASS FEES
Kids Classes
Classes for children ages 6-13 may be offered at a minimum of one (1) time per week
if so approved by Royce Gracie. The chapter representative may charge up to $40 per
month for the kids class. All children must have a consent signed by the parent or
guardian prior to beginning any class. Children 14 and over may participate in the
adult classes upon recommendation of the coach, assistant instructor or instructor.
Coach
A coach may charge the chapter members the following training fees:
1. A coach may charge up to $80 per month for regular group classes.
2. A coach may charge up to $30 per hour and/or $15 for ½ hour for a private
class.
3. A coach may charge up to $45 per hour for a semi-private class. There is a
maximum of 4 students per each semi-private lesson.
Assistant Instructor
An assistant instructor may charge the chapter members the following training fees:
1. An assistant instructor may charge up to $80 per month for regular group
classes.
2. An assistant instructor may charge up to $50 per hour and/or $25 for ½ hour
for a private class.
3. An assistant instructor may charge up to $75 per hour for a semi-private class.
There is a maximum of 4 students per each semi-private lesson.
Instructor
An instructor may charge the chapter members the following training fees:
1. An instructor may charge up to $80 per month for regular group classes.
2. An instructor may charge up to $80 per hour and/or $40 for ½ hour for a
private class.
3. An instructor may charge up to $120 per hour for a semi-private class. There
is a maximum of 4 students per each semi-private lesson.
A network representative must offer new or potential students a free introductory class.
DUES
Upon first establishing a Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ it is required that an applicant
pay a one time registration fee of $350. The registration fee includes:
1. Window Sign of the Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ Logo
2. A Certificate signed by Royce Gracie affirming your association as an
official location of a Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™
3. A certificate signed by Royce Gracie outlining classification within the
Network as either a Coach, Assistant Instructor or Instructor.
Each chapter representative will thereafter pay the Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ a
monthly membership fee of $200.00, payable on the 1st of each month by credit card.
In the event that a network representative operates more than 1 (one) location, such
locations and address shall be presented to Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™
administration and the chapter representative shall pay an additional monthly due(s) of
$200.00 per location.
It is not allowed for a student to continue regular training at the Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu
Network™ for longer than 15 days without becoming a member of the Network.
TOURNAMENTS & OTHER COMPETITION
Each chapter of the Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ or any member there of may
participate in Jiu-Jitsu tournaments and or other competitive events, including amateur
NHB/MMA events using the name and affiliation to the Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu
Network™ with prior permission by the network and Royce Gracie but not the name of
Royce Gracie directly.
Each network may additionally form a competition team comprised of the Royce Gracie
Jiu-Jitsu Network™ network members and/or members of Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu
Network™ from other networks, assuming that a representative of such network does not
object to such alliance.
In the event that a network representative wishes to organize and/or host a Jiu-Jitsu
tournament and use the name or the affiliation with Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™,
he/she must notify and receive expressed written permission from the Royce Gracie Jiu-
Jitsu Network™ administration. All tournaments must follow the rules and regulations
set forth by Royce Gracie and will be provided to the host prior to the tournament.
In the event that a network member is willing or will participate in any professional
NHB/MMA event they must contact the Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™
administration for additional information. They may otherwise not use the name Royce
Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™, Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu™, Royce Gracie, RGTV™ and/or
any other name signifying a direct or indirect association to Royce Gracie or any member
of his staff.
OTHER RULES & GUIDELINES
In the event that any Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ representative wishes to transfer
the network to another person(s) he/she must notify the Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu
Network™ administration in writing. Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ administration
must approve such a transfer before it can take effect and we reserve the right to deny or
revoke the current network affiliation.
In the event that a Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ representative wishes to cancel
his/her association with the Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ he/she must submit such
letter of cancellation to Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ administration in writing 30
days prior to cancellation to avoid continuation of monthly fees being charges. Upon the
termination of such affiliation the representative is responsible for removing Royce
Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ logo and certificate as well as any other material(s) including
but not limited to advertising, written information about the school, website information
and/or any other materials where Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ logo and/or
association to the Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ is mentioned.
In the event that a complaint is received by the Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™
administration about a network representative and/or a member of the Royce Gracie Jiu-
Jitsu Network™, we reserve the right to investigate such complaint(s) without prejudice
and the network representative agrees to offer the Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™
administration any and all information that is deemed necessary to resolve such
complain(s). In the event that Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ administration receives
an excessive amount of complaints about a network representative and/or a member of
the Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ and upon investigation the Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu
Network™ administration in its sole discretion believes that such complaints have merit,
Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ administration reserves the right to cancel such
Network Affiliation and/or revoke membership.
In the event that a network representative and or a member are found to be in violation of
this agreement the Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ administration reserves the right to
cancel such network and/or revoke membership.
It is not allowed for a network representative to manufacture clothing with Royce Gracie
Jiu-Jitsu Network™ logo and or Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu™, RGTV™, ATTITUDE™
and/or any other logo that is a trademark and/or a registered trademark of Royce Gracie
or KhonKhor Enterprises. All clothing to be sold thru a network location that bears or
resembles affiliation with any of the above names must be first approved by the Royce
Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™ administration.
LEGAL DISCLAIMER
The laws of the State of California shall govern this agreement and each party signing
this agreement submits to the jurisdiction of the State of California. Every part of this
Agreement will be considered servable. If for any reason any part of this Agreement is
held to be invalid, that determination will not impair the other parts of this Agreement
and the remainder of this Agreement shall be enforced as if the part found to be invalid
were not contained in the Agreement. In the event a dispute or controversy arises out of
or relating to this Agreement such dispute or controversy shall be resolved through
binding arbitration to be conducted in accordance with then current Commercial
Arbitration Rules of American Arbitration Association or in accordance with such other
arbitration rules as the parties may mutually agree upon. Judgment may be entered upon
any arbitration award in any court of competent jurisdiction. Arbitration shall be held in
Los Angeles, California.
This agreement may be amended by the Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™
administration, KhonKhor Enterprises, Inc. and/or any other party authorized by
KhonKhor Enterprises, Inc. Each chapter shall receive such amendment via Certified US
Mail and or United Parcel Service with signature required. No amendment shall be
enforced on a network unless it has been received by such network representative.
Both parties, as indicated, have executed this Agreement on the date below the signature.
__________________________________ __________________________________
Signature Print Name
KhonKhor Enterprises, Inc.
Date _____/_____/_____
__________________________________ __________________________________
Signature Print Name
Royce Gracie Jiu-Jitsu Network™
Chapter Representative

Date _____/_____/_____